Tally-Ho Restaurant Selma
Tally-Ho Restaurant Logo

Tally-Ho Restaurant

@

4.51105 reviews

Tally-Ho Restaurant offers a unique dining experience in Selma. It stands out for its vibrant atmosphere and excellent service. Warm wooden accents and a cozy fireplace create a welcoming ambiance. Perfect for families and friends, this restaurant turns a meal into a memorable event.

The menu features diverse American grill dishes, reflecting local flavors. Guests can savor everything from ribeye steaks to fried catfish. Each dish is crafted to provide comfort and joy. Tally-Ho brings people together over delicious food and good drinks. Enjoy a lively evening with live music on some nights.

About

Located at 509 Mangum Ave, Tally-Ho Restaurant has become a beloved spot in Selma. The building, originally a house, exudes charm and warmth. Over time, it has transformed into a vibrant hub for locals and visitors alike.

The restaurant embraces the spirit of community. Every corner of Tally-Ho tells a story of togetherness and celebration. It serves dishes that locals love, and its dedication to quality shines through in every plate. The owners and staff prioritize customer satisfaction, making each visit special.

Get in Touch

509 Mangum Ave, Selma, AL 36701, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 17:00-21:00
  • Tuesday 17:00-21:00
  • Wednesday 17:00-21:00
  • Thursday 17:00-21:00
  • Friday 17:00-22:00
  • Saturday 17:00-22:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Cute place. Looks like a house turned into a restaurant. Gumbo for soup of the day was delicious. The salmon was alright. The bourbon pecan pie was amazing with thr ice cream they served. Service was also great and the staff were friendly and helpful."

- Slanders P.

"Very good place Is very fancy We ordered: rib eye, filet and catfish. Of entree they put zuchinni muffins that are very good. We also ordered beer. Its a fancy place, i recommend here"

- Adrian N.

"Amazing always and the owner is the best! He has a great hardworking staff! I don't get to visit often enough, great food, atmosphere,and live bands on certain nights"

- Tammy F.

"Our group of 11 was visiting from out of town, and the staff impressed us right away with how quickly and smoothly they accommodated such a large party. The appetizers were excellent, and the small zucchini muffins were a standout favorite. Our server, Mae Mae, was warm, attentive, and made us feel genuinely welcome. When two members of our group mentioned they wanted to split an entree, the kitchen went above and beyond by plating two generous portions--an unexpected and much-appreciated touch. The atmosphere was inviting, the main dishes were well-prepared, and overall we had a fantastic experience. We've already agreed that this will be our go-to spot whenever we're back in the area."

- William E.

"It's a nice little restaurant tucked away in Selma, Al. The employees are friendly and welcoming. The menu items are some what limited and tends to be a little pricey. The food is good just not as good as expected considering the prices."

- Christin B.

"This was the best meal I've had in years. Everything was cooked and prepared to perfection. The staff were amazing. My wife and I dined here for the first time recently, and we were blown away. Will be recommending to everyone I know."

- Mike B.

"My wife and I took a road trip down to Selma from Birmingham to checkout the Tally-Ho because I had seen it mentioned on a top-10 list and it was worth the drive. We got the Ribeye and it was cooked perfectly and had a great flavor. The sides were good but I thought the potatoes were better than the cheese grits. We finished things up with their Creme Brule Cheesecake!"

- Jason P.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Tally-Ho Restaurant is a must-visit for its delightful atmosphere and diverse menu. Perfect for gatherings, the restaurant welcomes families, friends, and groups. The warmth of the people adds to the charm of the dining experience.

Must-try dishes include the ribeye steak and shrimp and grits. The fried green tomatoes are a local favorite, offering a taste of Southern cuisine. Pair your meal with one of the excellent cocktails or craft beers available.

Live music events provide a lively backdrop for dinner, enhancing the experience. Reserve a table on busy nights to ensure a superb dining experience. Happy hour deals make it a great spot for unwinding after a long day.

Accessibility options enhance inclusivity, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal together. Whether dining alone or with a large group, the service remains attentive and caring, creating a welcoming environment for all.

Most Liked things

Patrons love the cozy atmosphere of Tally-Ho. The friendly staff has garnered praise for their attentive service. The live music on select nights adds a vibrant touch to the dining experience.

Menu highlights, such as fried green tomatoes and ribeye, consistently receive rave reviews. The great selection of craft beers and cocktails enhances every meal. Guests appreciate the private dining spaces available for special occasions.

Most Disliked things

Some visitors have noted that the menu can feel limited at times. A few have mentioned that certain dishes carry higher prices than expected. The restaurant can get crowded during peak hours, especially on Friday nights. Longer wait times might occur for seating and service during busy periods.

Occasionally, the quality of dishes can vary based on the kitchen's workload. Raising concerns about specific experiences could lead to improvements. Maintaining quality is vital for overall satisfaction.

FAQ

What specialties does Tally-Ho Restaurant offer?

Tally-Ho features a diverse menu including ribeye, filet mignon, and a variety of local specialties. The seafood dishes like fried Gulf oysters and shrimp are also popular.

Are there vegetarian options at Tally-Ho?

Yes, Tally-Ho provides vegetarian options. Guests can enjoy a fresh house salad, seasonal veggies, or vegetable spring rolls as sides.

What is the price range for meals at Tally-Ho?

The price range at Tally-Ho is moderate, around $$. Meals are reasonably priced given the quality and portion sizes offered.

Is Tally-Ho accessible for individuals with mobility challenges?

Yes, Tally-Ho is fully accessible. It has accessible entrances, seating, and restrooms for everyone.

What ambiance can I expect at Tally-Ho Restaurant?

Tally-Ho provides a relaxed, upscale atmosphere. Enjoy the historic décor accompanied by live music and a warm fireplace.